Questão
de Ética
PT

Simplified version · Volume IV · chapter 9

Is It Necessary to Consume Animal Products?

In plain language, for readers who are new to the topic. About 2 min of reading.

What is this page? A simplified explanation written for this site based on Luciano Carlos Cunha’s text. It leaves out details, examples and sources. For the full argument, read the author’s original text.

The question

"But we need to eat animal products to be healthy, don't we?" If that were true, it would be a strong reason to consume them.

What the experts say

The answer is: it's not necessary. The Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, the largest association of nutrition professionals in the United States, concluded that a well-planned vegan diet is healthy and complete at every stage of life: pregnancy, breastfeeding, childhood, adolescence, adulthood, old age, and even for athletes.

It can also help prevent and treat some diseases.

"Well-planned"

That's true of any kind of diet. A diet with meat can also be bad if it's poorly planned. With a vegan diet, one important thing to watch is vitamin B12, which should be taken as a supplement or in fortified foods. A dietitian can help put together a balanced meal plan.

Why this matters

If we don't need animal products to be healthy, then consuming them is a choice, not a need. And the pleasure of a flavor doesn't outweigh an animal's life and suffering.

In short

  • You don't need to consume animal products to be healthy.
  • Major nutrition associations confirm this.
  • So consuming animals is a choice, not a need.

Next step

Now you are ready for the full text

The author’s text gives the arguments in detail, with examples, objections and the sources for every claim.

Read the original text