Questão
de Ética
PT

Simplified version · Volume VI · chapter 20

Does Every Living Being Have “Biological Interests”?

In plain language, for readers who are new to the topic. About 2 min of reading.

What is this page? A simplified explanation written for this site based on Luciano Carlos Cunha’s text. It leaves out details, examples and sources. For the full argument, read the author’s original text.

The argument

Animal advocates criticize the speciesism that ignores some of animals' interests just because they don't have all the interests humans have. Some biocentrists say: "You do the same to plants. They also have biological needs, like water, light, and nutrients. So they have interests too."

The answer

Beings who feel have an interest in eating, drinking, and resting. But that interest is instrumental: it matters because without those things, they suffer and can't have good experiences.

For a being that doesn't feel, meeting its biological needs has no value at all for it, because it has no point of view. There's nobody inside for whom it makes a difference.

"What about the interest in staying alive?"

Someone could say: "Eating and resting also serve to stay alive, which is a purely biological interest." But, as we've seen, staying alive matters because it lets you keep having experiences. Without experience, there's nobody for whom life matters.

In short

  • Having biological needs isn't the same as having interests.
  • For those who feel, needs matter because they affect their experiences.
  • For those who don't feel, there's nobody for whom anything matters.

Next step

Now you are ready for the full text

The author’s text gives the arguments in detail, with examples, objections and the sources for every claim.

Read the original text